Magento vs Shopify: Choosing the Right Platform for Your Business

Many businesses consider Magento and Shopify to determine which one best fits their eCommerce needs.

Considering the wide landscape of eCommerce ventures, choosing the right platform for your business is critical to remaining competitive. Whether you’re migrating a current store or setting up an entirely new endeavor, comparing some of the most popular options in the market, like Magento and Shopify, or a even a different option, can be greatly helpful.

In this guide, we’ll discuss the most important aspects of eCommerce and compare these two providers side-by-side. We’ll also discuss various features, pricing, and security and advise which option suits different business types and sizes best. With these insights, you can make an informed decision to optimize functionality and fees for you and your customers.

Shopify vs Magento: A Quick Overview

Both of these eCommerce giants empower thousands of global merchants with robust services for their online stores. However, they’re significantly different in their business processes.

Magento, recently rebranded as Adobe Commerce, is a popular platform that allows users to create, customize, and manage their own eCommerce websites. Magento comes in two main editions—Magneto Commerce and Magneto Open Source. Both options allow for extensive customization and are used by businesses of all sizes, from small startups to large enterprises.

Magento Open Source is the free version of the platform. Since it’s an open-source platform, users can modify the code to their specific needs. This offers a high level of detail and control; however, users need to manage hosting and are responsible for all the software updates, security, and maintenance. You will need to have some technical knowledge to optimize your store or hire a developer to create a unique and optimized site.

Magento Commerce is the premium, paid version of Magento. It offers full support, hosted cloud infrastructure, enhanced security, and a suite of pre-designed tools to simplify setup and management for non-technical users. Although you will pay a monthly fee, the store setup is fast and simple to navigate.

Founded in 2006, Shopify is one of the most widely used eCommerce platforms on the market. Shopify operates primarily as a software-as-a-service (SaaS) platform, which means it’s subscription-based and hosted by Shopify itself. This eliminates the need for users to manage web hosting or security certificates.

Known for being user-friendly, Shopify is more accessible for entrepreneurs and businesses without extensive technical knowledge to set up and run their eCommerce websites. The platform comes with various customization options and is suitable for businesses of almost any size.

Magento vs Shopify: In the Details

While Magneto and Shopify are both widely used eCommerce platforms, each has distinct features, strengths, and weaknesses. Understanding these differences will help you choose the most suitable platform for your business needs.

When it comes to Magneto and Shopify pricing, there are a wide variety of options to suit any budget. Both platforms allow you to start with a more cost-effective option and scale up as your business and budget grow. Remember that you also pay per-transaction fees on all sales besides your monthly fees and development costs.

Shopify Pricing

Shopify’s pricing plans start at $5 monthly and go up to $399 monthly. The Starter Plan ($5) caters to users who already have a store and simply wish to add social media selling capabilities. All other plans include a website, hosting, and the ability to take in-person payments via a mobile app.

The Basic Plan ($25) offers two staff access accounts and basic reporting features, while the Shopify Plan ($65) features five staff access accounts and professional reports. Shopify’s Advanced Plan ($399) is best for growing medium to large businesses that require advanced reporting. It features 15 staff access accounts and third-party calculated shipping rates.

To use a custom domain name without the Shopify branding in your URL, there’s an extra charge of $14 annually. If you opt for an annual subscription rather than a monthly payment, you’ll receive a 25% discount on the total subscription fee.

Shopify also offers an enterprise-level option that starts at $2,000 per month. This option offers custom transaction fee rates based on credit card sales volume and includes omnichannel commerce and B2B eCommerce features.

Magento Pricing

Unlike Shopify, which provides transparent pricing on its website, Magento Commerce requires you to contact its sales team for a quote. You can sign up for a free demo, but you’ll need to submit your information so that the Magento team can formulate a quote based on your business size and needs.

Downloading and using Magento Open Source is free, but you must pay for your domain registration, SSL certificates, and hosting plan. These services can cost from $5 to $30 monthly for hosting and $9 annually for a domain name. SSL certificates, which are necessary for website security, might come free with your hosting plan or cost as much as $100 annually.

By strategically selecting extensions and add-ons, you can build a cost-effective website. However, a high-functioning eCommerce site with many specialized features will most likely require paid premium templates and a knowledgeable development team.

Due to the many variables, the cost of a Magento Open Source store can vary greatly.

Customization is crucial for online stores to reflect their brand and mission. An intuitive and unique store interface can increase sales and lower bounce rates. Both Shopify and Magento offer various free and paid themes and templates but differ in flexibility and ease of use.

Shopify boasts a vast collection of themes that don’t require coding to rework the basic design. The platform simplifies the design process with a menu-driven approach to fonts and colors. It also features a theme editor for making layout changes and hiding sections for future updates without a staging server.

Its drag-and-drop interface is user-friendly, although not as advanced as a full builder. In terms of maintenance, Shopify automatically handles updates, whereas Magento users must manage them manually.

On the other hand, Magento offers more extensive customization due to its open-source nature. If you have web development expertise, you can control your store’s design. While its customization options are virtually limitless, the platform can be complex for those without coding experience.

While both platforms support responsive design for modern devices, Shopify provides an easier start for beginners. Although Shopify releases new themes periodically and allows you to customize certain aspects, everyone using the eCommerce platform has the same set of themes. This means that your store’s design elements will be similar to those of other businesses.

Shopify is a leading eCommerce platform largely due to its user-friendly design. Its clean, intuitive interface and drag-and-drop builder are simple to navigate, making product additions straightforward with clear prompts. Setting up a store is a fairly quick process compared to other platforms.

While feature-rich, Magento lacks user-friendliness compared to Shopify. As mentioned, the open-source version demands a high level of development expertise to configure. Even with Magento Commerce, which is slightly more accessible, the abundance of features can complicate the setup process, making it difficult to launch your store.

Shopify and Magento both offer extensive libraries of apps and extensions to enhance your online store. While some integrations are free, many will incur an additional cost. Shopify’s curated app store includes tools for loyalty programs, accounting, and email marketing. All apps are carefully vetted to ensure quality and security.

Meanwhile, Magento’s flexibility provides a significant advantage in terms of extensions. From payment gateway integrations to shipping options, marketing tools, inventory management, and SEO, store owners can add almost any features and capabilities to meet their specific and unique business needs. Additionally, many Marketplace integrations are from Magento Partners, who collaborate with Magento users to improve their store functionality.

Overall, both platforms provide an extensive range of add-ons. While Shopify’s integrations may offer ease of use, Magento provides flexibility and customization.

When comparing the features of Magento and Shopify, it’s important to note that the platforms serve somewhat different audiences. They also have different strengths based on the scale and scope of the eCommerce operations they’re designed for.

Shopify is geared toward ease of use. Its features cater to those who want an out-of-the-box solution with minimal technical involvement. Key features include:

• An intuitive drag-and-drop interface
• Integrated payment solutions with Shopify Payments
• 24/7 customer support
• Mobile optimization and apps for on-the-go store management
• A secure shopping cart that supports over 100 payment processors
• Click-to-buy links when listing products on Google, TikTok, Pinterest, eBay, Walmart, Facebook, Instagram, and other sites
• Inventory management tools to track stock levels set up inventory alerts, and handle transfers between locations
• Basic SEO features along with marketing tools such as gift cards and discounts
• POS capabilities

Magento is a more powerful platform often chosen by enterprises requiring scalability. The feature-rich platform offers extensive options for those with the technical skills or resources to manage it. Core features include:

• Ability to handle a large number of products and complex product options
• Advanced SEO capabilities
• Multi-store management from a single backend
• Powerful marketing, promotion, and conversion tools
• Instant checkout allows customers to easily checkout on one page
• Customer development features like guest or login checkout, email marketing campaigns, coupons, promotions, and product wishlists
• International commerce to manage multiple country sites and currencies, languages, and tax rates

Offering a wide range of payment options increases your attractiveness to customers. Magento and Shopify support all major credit and debit cards (Visa, MasterCard, American Express) and mobile wallets like Apple Pay and Google Pay.

Unlike Shopify, Magento does not offer its own built-in payment gateway. However, it supports over 300 payment extensions, such as PayPal, Stripe, and Amazon Payments. Magento does not charge any fees for using these external gateways; you’ll only incur the transaction fees levied by your bank or selected payment gateway.

Shopify also offers integration with numerous external payment gateways. However, depending on your plan, using them incurs extra fees of 0.5% to 2% per transaction. These fees are in addition to your transaction fees. When using Shopify Payments, Shopify’s integrated payment gateway, you eliminate this additional cost.

Shopify Payments transaction fees vary as follows depending on the plan you are on:

• Shopify Starter: 5% per transaction (online only)
• Basic Plan: 2.9% + $0.30 per online transaction and 2.7% for in-person transactions
• Shopify Plan: 2.6% + $0.30 per online transaction and 2.5% for in-person transactions
• Advanced Plan: 2.4% + $0.30 per online transaction and 2.4% for in-person transactions

Shopify Payments includes a fraud analysis feature and a streamlined process to respond and submit evidence to dispute chargebacks. However, bear in mind that Shopify Payments is not available in every country. Merchants located in unsupported countries must use a third-party payment gateway to process payments on their Shopify store and pay additional fees accordingly.

Shopify and Magento both offer valuable reporting and analytics capabilities that aid in making strategic business decisions. Shopify’s lower-tier plans only provide basic reporting capabilities. Upgraded plans offer an analytics dashboard, financial insights, product performance data, and detailed reports on orders, sales, and customer demographics.

Magento’s Reports Menu allows you to view multiple reports about sales, products, customers, and promotions. It offers data-rich dashboards, dynamic reports, and easily understandable data visualizations. The platform includes nine reporting dashboards, 100 predefined reports, and the ability to design and edit your custom reports.

When it comes to choosing an eCommerce platform based on security, both Magento and Shopify are known to prioritize customer data safety. However, due to their structural differences, they handle security a bit differently.

Since Shopify is a hosted platform, it controls the hosting environment. Because of this, Shopify takes care of a lot of the security for its users. This includes maintaining PCI compliance, providing SSL certificates for stores, and ensuring that its system is protected against attacks. Shopify can be a good choice for users who aren’t tech-savvy or don’t want to deal with the intricacies of securing their online store.

Magento’s security features differ between its two main products: Magento Open Source and Adobe Commerce. With Magento Open Source, you’ll need to take care of hosting, giving you more control and more responsibility for security. You must ensure PCI compliance, set up SSL, manage your servers, and implement security measures.

Adobe Commerce includes cloud hosting and additional security features, thus providing a more secure service similar to Shopify but with the flexibility Magento is known for.

Shopify vs Magento for Each Business Type: Which Is Better?

No matter whether you’re deciding between Magento, Shopify, or another option, the best solution is the one that meets the specific needs of your business. Here’s how each aligns with various business models.

Shopify is a common choice for startups since it offers more than just an online storefront. Shopify provides a suite of brand creation tools, including business name generation, free logo design, and personalized domain registration. It streamlines product sourcing by connecting users with reputable wholesalers and drop shippers.

Additionally, Shopify offers educational materials such as online courses, podcasts, and a blog to guide users in developing and expanding a successful business and in marketing their offerings.

Though not often the initial pick for startups, Magento provides robust adaptability for future expansion. Startups can opt for on-premise or cloud hosting with Adobe Commerce, which supports seamless integration of new technologies and enables the creation of app-style shopping experiences across various devices and channels. Furthermore, it simplifies the launch of new storefronts, allowing businesses to quickly adjust to their changing needs as they grow.

For small businesses, Shopify’s ease of use, transparent pricing structure, and ability to launch a store relatively quickly with pre-designed templates make it a more intuitive choice than Magento. In addition, security and maintenance are taken care of, and integrated payment processing with Shopify Payments eliminates the complexity of third-party payment gateways. Shopify offers 24/7 customer support, which can be a significant advantage for small business owners who may not have a dedicated IT team.

While Magento is extremely powerful and scalable, it typically requires more technical expertise to set up and manage. The costs associated with developing and maintaining a Magento site (such as hosting, security, and extensions) can be higher and might be more than what a small business initially needs.

However, if a small business has ambitious plans to scale up rapidly and requires specific customizations that Shopify cannot easily provide, Magento might be the better long-term choice despite the higher initial investment in time and resources.

Large corporations, on the other hand, may lean towards Magento or, at the very least, Shopify Plus. The Adobe Commerce edition of Magento is specifically designed for enterprise-level businesses. The platform is built to handle a large volume of products and transactions, scalable, and allows for managing multiple stores and websites from a single backend. In addition, Adobe Commerce has robust B2B features built into the platform. Magento integrates with various third-party applications and systems like ERP, CRM, and PIM. This makes it easy to sync the eCommerce platform with other business processes.

However, if one wants to use Shopify, the Shopify Plus enterprise solution generally makes the most sense for large corporations. It maintains Shopify’s user-friendly aspect while handling high volumes of sales and traffic. Shopify Plus provides dedicated support with a Merchant Success Manager and a Launch Engineer to help with setup and ongoing operations.

Making the Right Choice for Your eCommerce Success

The choice between Magento and Shopify hinges on your business’s specific needs, size, and technical capabilities. Shopify shines with its user-friendly interface, swift setup, and comprehensive support, making it ideal for small businesses and startups prioritizing ease of use and speed to market. With its detailed features and scalability, Magento appeals to businesses with complex needs and the technical resources to harness its full potential.

Both platforms empower online merchants to create compelling shopping experiences, but the right choice will align with your long-term vision and operational preferences. As you make this critical decision, remember that PaymentCloud is ready to work alongside you, offering tailored eCommerce payment processing solutions for a seamless and secure customer experience.

Whether you’re a completely new business, or a seasoned veteran looking to sharpen your knowledge about eCommerce, we’re here to help.

Get a Merchant Account